Florida AG Declares 2018 Bump-Stock Ban Unconstitutional, Won’t Defend Convictions

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier is drawing a hard line. On Nov. 13, 2026, he issued an opinion finding that Florida’s § 790.222 bump-stock ban violates the Second Amendment. His office will no longer defend convictions under the 2018 law. This is not a political feint. It is an attorney general putting the Constitution ahead of a statute.

The opinion follows the U.S. Supreme Court’s Cargill decision, which struck down the federal bump-stock rule. Washington’s regulation is gone. Florida’s ban is not. Uthmeier’s finding treats that leftover prohibition as a Second Amendment problem and withdraws his office from defending the convictions built on it. After Cargill, the federal rule cannot carry the state’s case. The attorney general has now refused to carry it himself.

Florida AG Declares 2018 Bump-Stock Ban Unconstitutional, Won’t Defend Convictions

Section 790.222 remains Florida law. Existing state prosecutions under the 2018 bump-stock ban now proceed without the attorney general’s backing. The office that would ordinarily defend those judgments in court has stepped aside. Convictions already obtained sit without that support. Efforts to sustain them will not have the AG’s lawyers at counsel table.

That decision is a refusal, not a repeal. The legislature wrote § 790.222. Uthmeier has not erased the text. He has judged it unconstitutional and declined to spend the state’s legal resources keeping its convictions alive. Prosecutors and trial courts are left with files the state’s top lawyer will not defend.

Attorneys general swear an oath to the Constitution of the United States. When a state gun ban collides with the Second Amendment, that oath does not require them to keep arguing for the ban. Uthmeier has chosen the right over the 2018 statute. Cargill struck down the federal bump-stock rule. The Florida attorney general has now judged the 2018 state ban unconstitutional under the Second Amendment and walked away from the convictions it produced.

What happens next is litigation without the AG. Section 790.222 still sits in the Florida statutes. Convictions under it still exist. They will not be defended by James Uthmeier’s office. The right to keep and bear arms does not yield to a 2018 ban the state’s own attorney general will no longer stand behind.

References

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top